Veteran owned · Independent · Springfield, IL

Insurance agency in Springfield and all of Illinois

Veteran-owned, faith-driven, and trusted by more than 1,000 Springfield families.

At Bailey Family Insurance, we make the process of finding the best insurance simple again. Because our agency is 100% independent, we have the freedom to shop you with our 30+ top rated carriers to find you the best possible combination of cost and coverage on your car insurance and home insurance. Start a conversation with us today.

The Bailey Family Insurance office in Springfield, Illinois The Bailey Family Insurance office in Springfield, Illinois

5.0 on Google

1,000+ five-star reviews

  • 1,000+ Five-star Google reviews
  • 30+ Top-rated carriers
  • 2017 Serving Springfield families since

Google reviews

Springfield families, in their own words

5.0
Rated 5.0 from 1,000+ Google reviews
Read our reviews
  • Beat my previous home and car rates. That's the most important. Now let's talk exceptional customer service… This office is clean, courteous, and professional.

    Pam McGeeNovember 2026

  • She was able to get me a quote and finalize my homeowners insurance within just a few days… it was nice to actually be able to talk to a person instead of a bot!

    Kyle AngeliNovember 2026

  • Taylor was easy to work with when I needed a builders risk policy. 10/10 - Would Recommend!

    TJ GanskyNovember 2026

  • I was immediately drawn by the information that this is a veteran owned independent and faith based agency. I looked no further and now know I didn't need to.

    Linda SharpNovember 2026

  • Excellent customer service! Very knowledgeable, helpful, and always willing to go the extra mile. Made my homeowners insurance process easy and stress-free.

    PaulaNovember 2026

  • Nick Rector was great, found me great coverage with reasonable price, highly recommend

    P&T Properties LLCOctober 2026

  • Taylor helped me save so much on my home owners insurance. The process was so easy!

    Mikia NewcomerNovember 2026

  • I spoke with Keely who was AWESOME!!! She got me BETTER coverage at half the cost. YES half the cost!!!

    Shawn DeVillezOctober 2026

  • I made 1 phone call and was treated with such FANTASTIC service within 1/2 hr I had coverage and plan on getting homeowners also

    Marlene HensonOctober 2026

  • Austin was incredible. Very knowledgeable and was able to help with all my questions and concerns. Got me a great deal with very little hassle

    Jacob BergmanOctober 2026

  • Taylor is very knowledgeable, and was able to set me up with a policy that had better coverage for less money. Very good communication as well.

    Dale YutzySeptember 2026

  • I was so worried when I got the letter from my homeowners insurance company saying they were closing but, I called Bailey Family Insurance and Taylor sent me a quote, and got me insurance today!

    Theresa Stumper-WallaceAugust 2026

  • Mikaelah at Bailey Family Insurance is fantastic to work with! She took the time to understand what we needed and made several adjustments along the way when I had questions.

    Erin GutzmanSeptember 2026

  • Prompt, Informative communication. Great price. Friendly service. Professionalism at its finest. Taylor Thomson was a pleasure to work with.

    Aaron WellsSeptember 2026

  • I was unsure about switching Insurance companies, but was very pleasantly surprised to see how much money I will be saving and still getting the same coverage I previously had.

    Anna LawyerJuly 2026

  • Great at explaining insurance policy information and communicating with clients. 100% would recommend him and BFI to anyone looking for an insurance agent!

    Madisyn PaigeSeptember 2026

  • Leona did a wonderful job assisting me. Took all of maybe 10 minutes to get me on my way. Highly recommend BFI

    Jacob DowersAugust 2026

  • Bailey Family Insurance is always looking out for ways to save me money and keep me informed of changes and opportunities for additional benefits whether car, home or life insurance they are on it!

    Andrea LukaSeptember 2026

  • Austin was very helpful and got me an incredible quote… very quick with his help in saving almost $100 a month from switching companies

    Lucy HopperAugust 2026

  • Great communication and good, accurate quotes. Austin Sprouse was very easy to work with!

    Matthew HumphreyAugust 2026

Insurance doesn't have to be complicated. With us, it's not. We're the trusted advisor you never knew you needed.
Bailey Family Insurance · Springfield, IL

Personal & commercial insurance

No matter what type of insurance protection you're looking for, we've got you covered - literally and figuratively.

The Bailey Family Insurance team
57% Average annual rate reduction

Why independent

With Bailey Family Insurance, you've got a plethora of insurance carrier & coverage options

Gone are the days of calling around from broker to broker trying to pin down the right coverage and an honest price. We understand your time is valuable, so we shop and compare top companies on your behalf so you don't have to stress.

Insurance is never just about price, but we deliver when it comes to saving you money

Because our agency is 100% independent, we have multiple options and can compare the best available policies for you. With flexible coverage and deductible options, we can find solid coverage for any budget. Because we shop 30+ carriers on your behalf, we can find coverage that fits your needs and your budget — something a single-company quote simply can't do.

Independent vs. captive vs. direct

One call. 30+ carriers. An agent who works for you.

Most insurance is sold one of three ways. Here is how an independent agency like Bailey Family Insurance compares with a captive agent, who sells for a single company, and a direct call center.

Compare Bailey Family Insurance with

How Bailey Family Insurance compares with a captive agent and a direct call center
What you get Bailey Family InsuranceIndependent agency Captive agentSells for one company Direct call centerBuy from the company
Who they work for You, the client One insurance company One insurance company
Carriers compared for you 30+ top-rated carriers One One
When your rate goes up We can re-shop your coverage across our carriers Options stay within one company You start shopping over on your own
Who you talk to The same Springfield team that knows you A local agent Whoever answers the queue
Personal and business coverage Home, auto, life, and business under one roof Limited to what one company offers Usually personal lines only
Help when you file a claim We advocate for you with the carrier Agent can help, within one company Handled through a claims phone line

How it works

Curious about our process? It's really easy!

We do all of the heavy lifting for you, all we need is some basic information to get started 🙂

Start a quote
  1. 1

    Start Online

    Enter some basic info on our website.

  2. 2

    We Shop For You

    We check with multiple insurance carriers.

  3. 3

    Choose Your Plan

    We present multiple options to pick from.

Veteran owned & operated

Veteran-owned. Faith-driven. Family-run.

The Bailey family of Bailey Family Insurance

Bailey Family Insurance is a veteran-owned agency. The habits that come with service are the ones we run our office on: show up, keep your word, and look out for the people who count on you.

People often ask, “Why are you different or better than my current company?” It's simple - our people

What sets our agency apart is our people, processes, and our personality. Our team cares, and we go the extra mile every day. We won't rest until every client has had a truly amazing experience with us.

Meet the team

Switching to us

Have questions about the process of switching to us?

Get answers to some frequently asked questions below.

Springfield Insurance FAQ
What are the benefits of switching to you?

There are many reasons we feel that we're a great choice to help with your insurance. Maybe the biggest one is that our agency is 100% independent and can offer you many choices when it comes to coverage and insurance providers. This saves you hours of time in trying to compare the different options yourself 🙂

How do we switch to you?

When you're ready to switch over to our agency, you'll first need to secure coverage with the carrier we found for you. This usually involves making an initial down payment and signing off on the policies we present to you. The process is very simple and only takes a matter of minutes.

Do you shop my insurance every year?

While we can definitely revisit your policies on an annual basis, changing insurance carriers every year (or six months) can actually negatively impact your “insurance score” which can actually cause your rates to increase. Therefore, while it's possible, we don't necessarily recommend it.

We're here to help make sense of insurance. Start a conversation with us today.

Our friendly team of agents will help save you time, aggravation, and money 🙂

957 Clocktower Drive, Springfield, IL 62704

Call Email Claims Quote